Answer: HOLLY

To determine this, look at who is higher ranked in each column of the preference schedule (and by how many voters).


# of Voters



13 12 10
1st G I J
2nd H H G
3rd J J H
4th I G I

Holly is preferred to James by the 13 voters in the first column and the 12 voters in the second column for a total of 25 votes. James is preferred to Holly in the other column, giving James 10 votes. So, Holly beats James in a head-to-head matchup. Since Holly won, we put her name in the appropriate cell of the head-to-head matchup table.

  George Holly James Inez
George ---------- GEORGE JAMES GEORGE
Holly ---------- ---------- HOLLY  
James ---------- ---------- ----------  
Inez ---------- ---------- ---------- ----------